Shadow Work’s Greatest Enemy (Journaling is A Scam)

Demystifying Shadow Work

18.09.24

I’ve been truly concerned about the general advice around the shadow integration process. Instead of people reading Carl Jung’s books, they come up with the craziest things.

First of all, you’ll never integrate the shadow by journaling or doing weird meditations and visualizations, this will just get you stuck. In fact, many people report feeling worse when they undertake these practices.

If you want to truly integrate the shadow, you have to learn the original psychological principles postulated by Carl Jung.

In this article, we’ll go over 3 things:

  • What is The Shadow and How To Integrate It.
  • How To Combat The Greatest Enemy of Shadow Integration that get people stuck.
  • How to Uncover The Good Qualities of your Shadow and start creating your audacious life.

The Shadow

According to Carl Jung, the shadow contains repressed and undeveloped aspects of our personality and you probably felt its effects many times in your life. Do you know when you’re so mad that you say and do things that you immediately regret?

Whenever you feel like you’re not yourself, act compulsively, or give in to an addiction, these are the works of the shadow. It feels like something completely external to us is pulling the strings and we’re just a puppet, that’s why Carl Jung says that shadow has a “possessive” quality.

But contrary to popular belief, the shadow isn’t made of only undesired qualities. The shadow is neutral and the true battle often lies in accepting the good qualities of our shadow, such as our hidden talents, creativity, and all of our untapped potential, but we’ll get to that in a moment.

The Puppet Masters

Carl Jung explains that the personal shadow is mainly formed by complexes and they’re the real puppet masters behind every symptom of anxiety, depression, and toxic relationship patterns. Complexes produce narratives in our minds that can distort our interpretation of reality and shape our sense of identity.

For instance, when you’re dealing with an inferiority complex, you’ll usually have a dramatic voice in your head telling you that you’re not enough and you don’t matter, and you’ll never be able to be successful and will probably just die alone.

You live in fear and never go after what you truly want because deep down you feel like you don’t deserve it. Secretly, you feel jealous of the people who have success, but you’re afraid to put yourself out there. Then, you settle for mediocre relationships and a crappy job.

When you’re under the influence of the shadow, it f*king hurts! It feels like there’s no way out because there are stories playing on repeat on our minds dragging us down and influencing our behaviors and decisions.

The only way to break free from these narratives is by first taking the time to understand them. There are complexes and destructive narratives around money and achieving financial success, about our self-image and capabilities.

The origin of many of these narratives is the mother and father complex and you can learn more about that in this video – Conquer The Puer and Puella Aeternus

The Projected Inner Theater

Moreover, complexes are the basis for our projections and directly influence our relationships. This means that we unconsciously engage with people to perpetuate these narratives.

For instance, someone with intimacy issues will have the tendency to go after emotionally unavailable people who can potentially abandon them. Or they will find a way to sabotage the relationship as soon as it starts to get serious.

Complexes feel like a curse, we find ourselves living the same situations over and over again. One of the most important keys to integrating the shadow is learning how to work with our projections, as everything that is unconscious is first encountered projected.

I won’t get technical in this article, but you can find a step-by-step to integrate the shadow in my book PISTIS – Demystifying Jungian Psychology. Go on and grab your copy!

The Inner Gold

But after all of that, you must be thinking that complexes can only be bad. Is there even hope?

Well, it’s our conscious attitude that determines how these complexes will operate.

For instance, most people have a bad relationship with anger and do everything they can to repress it, thinking it’s the works of Satan, haha.

The problem is that the more we repress it, the more it rebels against us, that’s why when it finally finds an outlet it’s this huge possessive thing.

However, when anger is properly channeled it gives us the ability to say now and place healthy boundaries. It can give us the courage to end bad relationships and becomes an important fuel to help us achieve our goals such as our independence and financial success.

If you take only one thing from this article, remember this: The key to integrating the shadow lies in transforming our perception of what’s been repressed and taking the time to give these aspects a more mature expression through concrete actions.

For instance, most people nowadays don’t pay attention to their creativity and think it’s completely useless to have an “unproductive hobby”. As a result, they tend to be restless, emotionally dry, and have the wildest dreams with beasts and weird animals pursuing them.

Well, usually when something is pursuing us in a dream, it’s because it’s trying to reach our conscious mind but it can’t because of our rigid conscious attitude. The form of a beast also indicates how repressed it is.

This obviously depends on context and it can be a positive or negative aspect, but more often than not, we’re resisting integrating positive aspects of our personality and our creative potential.

Shadow Work’s Greatest Enemy

This leads us to my final point, “Insight into the myth of the unconscious must be converted into ethical obligation” – Carl Jung.

The Shadow holds the key to uncovering our hidden talents, being more creative, building confidence, creating healthy relationships, and achieving meaning and purpose.

But there’s a huge problem, my experience as a therapist taught me that 99% of people know exactly what they want in life and what they have to do, however, they allow fear to get in the way.

That’s why the greatest enemy of shadow integration is not transforming these insights into practical action. This leads to being stuck in the past and being completely engulfed by the overwhelming negative emotions of our shadow.

The first thing that traumatic experiences do is make us disconnect from our bodies and the practical aspects of life, we’re never present. That’s why journaling, meditations, and visualizations tend to make people feel worse.

It promotes passivity, people get stuck in their heads and never embody their discoveries. Carl Jung never proposed anything like that, he constantly focused on the importance of concrete action.

Moreover, the body is one of the main expressions of Eros and our instinctual life, but in today’s society, it’s been completely relegated to the shadows. It’s rare to find someone who’s in touch with their own emotional natures and truly accepts and lives in their bodies.

What ends up happening is that this split is compensated by vices and addictions. That’s why bodywork and approaches like Somatic Experiencing can be essential to integrate the shadow.

I explore this in-depth in my video How To TRULY Heal From Trauma

As a rule of thumb, I don’t recommend exploring the unconscious if you can’t emotionally regulate first and have solid roots in reality such as healthy habits, good relationships, and work-related responsibilities.

Integrating The Shadow

Finally, the general advice around shadow work is “to find the roots of your trauma”, if it’s not working, it’s because you didn’t go deep enough”. Sure, it’s important to understand the origins of neurosis.

However, this approach is too intellectual and always leads to excessive rationalizations. People get addicted to reading book after book and watching video after video, but they never do anything in real life and get engulfed by the shadow.

Let’s say you always wanted to be a musician or a writer but you never went for it because you didn’t want to disappoint your parents and you doubted your capabilities. You choose a different career and these talents are now repressed.

After a few years, you realize that you must attend this calling. You can spend some time learning why you never did it in the first place, like how you gave up on your dreams and have bad financial habits just like your parents. Or how you never felt you were good enough because you experienced toxic shame.

This is important in the beginning to evoke new perspectives and help challenge these beliefs, but most people stop there. But in the end, the only thing that matters is what you do with your insights.

You can only integrate the shadow by devoting time and energy to developing these repressed aspects and making practical changes.

In this case, you’d need to make time to write, maybe take classes, and you’d have to decide if this is a new career or if it’ll remain a sacred hobby, etc. You integrate the shadow and further your individuation journey by doing and following your fears.

That’s why filling out prompts will get you nowhere. If you realize you have codependent behaviors, for instance, you don’t have to “keep digging”, you have to focus on fully living your life, exploring your talents, and developing intrinsic motivation.

Btw, I have a great video about this called The Definitive Guide To Overcome Love Addiction.

Lastly, working with prompts goes completely against what Carl Jung proposed with his Active Imagination method. For journaling to be effective, you need to have a living dialogue with the unconscious.

This only happens when you engage with automatic writing and then challenge the answers you receive. It’s a dialectical procedure between the conscious ego and the unconscious perspective, but even this will be useless if you don’t act on your discoveries.

With dreams, it’s the same thing. We constantly receive messages from the unconscious and interpreting it is the easy part, what mattes is if you follow it.

As a final note, I hope you understand I’m not against journaling and meditation as I frequently do it. I’m against how people use it in the Shadow Work context, as I constantly see people on Reddit saying how they were traumatized by it. You shouldn’t play with the unconscious, you have to approach it with care and respect.

PS: You can find a complete guide to the shadow integration process, that covers the theory and the practical aspects in my best-selling and accessible course Katabasis – The Shadow Integration Manual

Rafael Krüger – Live an Audacious Life


Whenever you’re ready, there are 3 ways I can help you:

  • Katabasis – The Shadow Integration Manual – My best-selling and accessible course will introduce you to all you need to know to disrupt the unconscious patterns keeping you stuck.
  • Audacity University – My flagship course contains a  4-year psychology curriculum and gives you access to the Audacity Inner Circle and live meetings.
  • Mentorship – Catalyze your personal transformation with 1 on 1 sessions. Master your psychology, relationships, and business.

Sign Up For The Audacity Newsletter

Esse website utiliza cookies

Para otimizar sua experiência de navegação, usamos cookies. Ao continuar no site, assumimos que você concorda com nossa Política de Privacidade.